Black and red maca roots and powders

Black Maca vs. Red Maca: What the Human Trial Compared

Nov 17, 2026Organic Fuel

Black and red maca were compared in a human trial, but the color alone did not tell readers which to choose. The results depended on the outcome the researchers measured and where the participants lived.

What the human trial compared

In a 2016 randomized, placebo-controlled trial, 175 adults at low and high altitude in Peru received spray-dried black maca extract, spray-dried red maca extract, or placebo for 12 weeks. The researchers measured several outcomes, including self-reported sexual desire, mood and energy. In the low-altitude group, the apparent advantage for red maca on perceived sexual desire was not statistically significant compared with placebo. That comparison does not establish that red maca is better for libido generally.

Match the claim to what was measured

Perceived sexual desire differs from erectile function, a testosterone result, or a fertility outcome. An energy rating also differs from a timed athletic test. When comparing articles or product claims, check the exact outcome, the group that was studied, and whether the authors compared groups or simply reported a change over time.

Check what the package specifies

Look for the stated maca color, plant part, preparation and amount per labeled serving. A powder or a mixed-color blend may differ from the extracts used in the trial. If the package doesn't identify the extract or the amount of each component, ask the manufacturer rather than estimating. If you are considering maca because of a symptom or have medicine questions, show the exact label to a clinician or pharmacist.

Disclosure: Organic Fuel sells supplements. Our guide to libido remedies explains how to compare symptom claims with the study outcome.

More articles

Comments (0)

There are no comments for this article. Be the first one to leave a message!

Leave a comment

Please note: comments must be approved before they are published